Dodge City, KS24 posts · joined Nov 2025Keystone Cougar 29RLK · Ram 2500
the handle is honest, i tow with a 2500, a 2017 Ram 2500 Cummins crew cab with the 6.4 foot bed. right now i pull a Cougar 29RLK that scales around 9,400 loaded with a pin around 1,650, and the truck handles it fine. but the family is outgrowing the 29 and i am looking at moving up to something in the 12,000 pound range with a bigger rear living room floorplan, and the pin on those is going to be 2,300 to 2,600 loaded.
so the question i cannot get a straight answer to anywhere: does a 12,000 pound fifth wheel force me into a 3500, or will the 2500 do it. and if i am buying a one ton anyway, single rear wheel or do i jump to a dually. half the internet says a 2500 is plenty and the other half says anybody towing over 10k without a dually is going to die, and both of them are yelling.
i am not married to Ram, i will buy whatever makes sense, i just know this platform. what i care about is doing it right, not winning an argument at the dump station.
Glenn P.Moderator#2
Sierra Vista, AZ16 posts · joined Nov 2025Solitude 310GK · Ram 3500 dually · B&W Companion
stop asking 2500 vs 3500 and start reading the yellow payload sticker in the driver's door jamb, because that is the only number that answers your actual question. the badge on the tailgate is marketing. a 2500 and a 3500 single rear wheel are frequently the same truck with different springs and a sticker, and the gap between a gas 2500 and a diesel dually 3500 in payload can be 2,000 pounds or more.
do the math that actually matters. take the truck's payload number off the door. subtract the weight of everybody who rides in it, the hitch itself, a full tank of fuel, the firewood and the generator in the bed. what is left is what you have for pin weight. a loaded 12,000 pound fifth wheel puts 2,300 to 2,600 pounds on the pin, and i have watched a lot of nice crew cab diesel 2500s that only had 1,900 pounds of payload left after the family got in. that truck is over its rear axle and over its GVWR before the trailer is level, and it will still tow it down the road feeling fine, which is the trap.
my honest line: a 12,000 pound fifth wheel is a one ton trailer. a 3500 single rear wheel with the high payload will usually do it legally if you watch the options. a dually does not tow harder, it carries the pin with more rear tire under it and it is steadier in a crosswind and when a semi passes you on a downgrade. for 12k a SRW one ton is enough for most people. the day you look at 15,000 pounds and a 3,200 pound pin, the dually stops being a preference.
pin_weight_watcherWeekender#3
Ogden, UT21 posts · joined Nov 2025Jayco Eagle 321RSTS · GMC Sierra 3500 SRW
i am the example Glenn is describing except i went the right way. i tow a Jayco Eagle 321RSTS, pin around 2,540 loaded, with a Sierra 3500 single rear wheel that has just under 4,100 pounds of payload on the door sticker. after the two of us, the dog, and the hitch and a full tank, i have about 1,200 pounds of margin over the pin. legal, steady, and i did not need the dually.
i cross-shopped a 2500 version of the same truck when i bought and the payload on the door was 2,650. with my pin that truck is over before anybody climbs in. same truck to look at, 1,400 pounds less capacity on paper. the sticker is the whole story.
go to the scale with your current rig first. weigh your real loaded pin and weigh your truck the way you actually travel, then you are shopping with numbers instead of opinions.
montana_high_countrySnowbird#4
Rapid City, SD26 posts · joined Nov 2025Montana High Country 331RL · Ford F-350 SRW
i pull a Montana High Country 331RL, right around 12,500 loaded with a pin close to 2,700, with an F-350 single rear wheel. so i am living exactly at the number you are asking about. it is legal on my door sticker with about 800 pounds to spare, and it tows great in still air.
where i feel the single rear wheel is the Wyoming wind on I-25 and getting passed by a double trailer on a downhill. the rig wags a little and i correct it, it is not scary, but my buddy with the dually version does not correct anything in the same gust. if i lived where it was flat and calm i would not think about it. out here on the high plains in the wind i think about it a couple times a trip, and if i were buying again at this weight i would probably get the dually just for the crosswind manners.
andersen_hitch_userWeekender#5
Green Bay, WI19 posts · joined Nov 2025Forest River Sandpiper 321RL · Ford F-250 short bed
one more thing to fold into the decision since nobody has said it yet: the bed length. i tow with a short bed F-250 and a slider style hitch, and if you move up to a one ton you get to decide short bed or long bed too. a long bed one ton takes a fixed hitch and never worries about the cab in a tight turn. a short bed wants a slider or an Andersen style hitch so the cap of the fifth wheel does not meet your back window at full lock.
not telling you which, just do not pick the truck and forget that the bed length changes which hitch you can run and how tight a gas station you can back out of. i can give you the short bed hitch rundown in another thread if you go that way.
towing_with_a_2500OPWeekender#6
Dodge City, KS24 posts · joined Nov 2025Keystone Cougar 29RLK · Ram 2500
Glenn P. wrotestop asking 2500 vs 3500 and start reading the yellow payload sticker in the driver's door jamb.
went and read mine. my 2017 2500 has 2,210 pounds on the door sticker. me, my wife, two kids, the hitch and a full tank is about 1,500 of that already on a travel day, so i have maybe 700 pounds of pin. that is fine for the 29RLK at 1,650 only because the kids and most of the weight are not in the truck when i actually weighed it, and barely. for the 12,000 pound rig i want, the 2500 is done. the sticker ended the argument in about a minute, exactly like you said.
so the plan is a 3500. i priced both configurations on the Ram build site at ramtrucks.com and the dually crew cab is not much more money than the SRW the way i would option it, and living in the Kansas wind like montana_high_country describes, i think i want the dually. going to weigh the truck loaded for a trip this week so i am shopping the new rig with a real leftover-payload number instead of a guess.
desert_snowbirdSnowbird#7
Yuma, AZ28 posts · joined Nov 2025Reflection 297RSTS · Ram 3500
late to this but i will add the snowbird angle since i do the long hauls. i run a 3500 dually under a Reflection 297RSTS and the dually earns it every october on the drive down I-10 when the side wind off the open desert hits, and again in the Phoenix crosswinds. for somebody who only moves the rig a few times a year a SRW one ton is plenty. for somebody putting on real highway miles in open country twice a year the dually is quieter in the shoulders and i never think about it.
and a used truck note for your shopping. a one ton that was a work truck may have been loaded hard its whole life, so when you are buying, look at the rear springs and the frame behind the axle, not just the miles. a dually that hauled a welding rig is a different animal than one that pulled a camper on weekends.
Log in to reply. No account yet? Ask a mod, it takes a day or two.